Showing posts with label Liberal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Liberal. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

What's Really Important to President Obama?

Micheal Sean Winter, writing in the National Catholic Reporter captures exactly the frustration of classic liberals with President Obama. As I have written in earlier posts the liberals shunned in the move of the Democratic party far to the right in the 80s and 90s are now spread over Democratic, Republican and Independent categories but they do vote with a conscience. 

"I confess I no longer understand Obama. He did not go to the mat to end the Bush tax cuts for the super-rich. He did not go to the mat for comprehensive immigration reform. He did not go to the mat to close Guantanamo Bay. He did not go to the mat for Card Check. He did not go to the mat for a public option in the health care reform. But, he went to the mat over the principle that a Catholic college or charity or hospital is not really religious.

The president not only is the chief magistrate of the land, he is the leader of the Democratic Party. I know I am something of an odd duck by being what I call an “Ella Grasso Democrat.” Grasso was the first woman to be elected a governor of her state in her own right, not succeeding her husband. She was pro-labor. She was pro-Israel. She was pro-higher taxes on rich folk. She stood up for the little guy. Unlike other male Democrats – Kennedy and Gore and Gephardt and Muskie – she remained pro-life. I believe that it is the historic calling of the Democratic Party to stand up to the moneyed interest and say that the common good, not just the individual pursuit of profit, is a moral obligation and a necessity in a free and just society. I am simply not interested in a Democratic Party that is so beholden to the fundraisers at Emily’s List, so consumed with lifestyle politics, that it is willing to thumb its nose at those working class voters who really do care about social justice and for whom that care is a part of their religious beliefs. And, if liberals no longer care about a robust defense of the First Amendment, well, then, we do not deserve the presidency. "  (Michael Sean Winters in National Catholic Reporter)

Read the rest of his article here. He is a Catholic, a liberal and a blogger who understands how the conservative Democrats forced liberal Catholics, Labor Unionists and human rights activists out of the party or essentially silenced them starting in the 80s.

Yes I know that Deacon Greg posted this same quote but my minuscule audience most likely has little overlap with his huge audience and mine needs to read this also.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Pro Life Roots

This week's America Magazine has several excellent articles on the roots of the Pro Life Movement in the US which existed prior to Roe v Wade, the role of Catholics in the recent election and the multigenerational impact of abortion on a family.

Human rights support, for Catholics, begin in the Church's social doctrine. The right of all humans to life itself is violated daily in our world. Vatican II published a list of actions opposed to life. The list is as follows.


PASTORAL CONSTITUTION ON THE CHURCH IN THE MODERN WORLD (1964)

(from Section 27)"Furthermore, whatever is opposed to life itself, such as any type of murder, genocide, abortion, euthanasia or wilful self-destruction, whatever violates the integrity of the human person, such as mutilation, torments inflicted on body or mind, attempts to coerce the will itself; whatever insults human dignity, such as subhuman living conditions, arbitrary imprisonment, deportation, slavery, prostitution, the selling of women and children; as well as disgraceful working conditions, where men are treated as mere tools for profit, rather than as free and responsible persons; all these things and others of their like are infamies indeed. They poison human society, but they do more harm to those who practice them than those who suffer from the injury. Moreover, they are supreme dishonor to the Creator."

How We (Mis)Treat Our Friends

My own pro life activism dates to the mid 1960s. I remember taking the pro life side in debates held by our local democratic club. I fully expected that opposition to abortion was the next task of the human rights activists, liberals and Democrats. Over the next decade the anti human rights (and anti religious) faction succeeded in moving the Democratic Party to the right. In the process liberals, trade unionists and religious Democrats were progressively alienated. See my earlier post as to the resulting fragmentation of human rights supporters.

Canadian Pro Life supporters face a different situation than we in the US yet they seem to share our tendency to shoot ourselves in the foot by mistreating our friends. For a view of the resulting frustration read a Canadian Pro Lifer Blogger's posting.

After an absence of over thirty years I was pleased to find pro life liberals still active and successful in Minnesota. Yet the recent elections confirmed again the tendency of many pro life activists to alienate their friends. While the Minnesota Right To Life community endorses pro life candidates of any party this is not the case in many states. The National Human Rights Organization That I have been part of for at least thirty years angered me a few elections ago by not endorsing our pro life Congressman, a Democrat, even though he was opposed by a pro abortion Republican.

We now have a President that has taken strong pro life stands against torture, war and genocide. He even said, this week, that the value of all human life demands we work together to reduce abortions. You can bet that a fair number of statements will be made insisting that we can't join in that effort because the President falls short of our ideals. We will again appear to be willing to accept the death of many more babies rather than sully our hands with incremental progress.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Obama's gives comprehensive answers but trips over his achilles heal.

While John McCain’s performance at the California Church was a definite disappointment the responses of Barach Obama revealed a comprehensive grasp of the dire predicament in which our country finds itself . In particular he excelled in his answers to the questions about evil and economic diversity while McCain was embarrassingly shallow on these these critical issues.

Obama’s achilles heal is the subject of abortion where his continued acceptance of money and support from the abortion industry lobbyists and PACs is totally contradictory to the positions he so elegantly discussed moments before. In this segment of the interview he seemed to excuse or even regret his denial of rights to babies born alive during an attempted abortion. He offered the excuse that the measure (In Illinois) did not contain a certain amendment.

Fortunate for us the business of the Illinois legislature is a matter of public record. The bill did contain the amendment he described. What is also in the record is his arguments against the bill. Essentially he argued that the lives of such children should not be protected because they would be an embarrassment to the abortionist. While he now says he would support such law an apology would have been more appropriate than the misleading and incorrect excuse he did offer. This glaring inconsistency with the rest of his answers was most disappointing.

Disappointing but not surprising. In his best seller, The Audacity of Hope, he made it clear in his story of his entry to politics that his funding came from the abortion lobby. He revealed this by saying that he could not accept funds from the human rights organization and PAC (lobby) to which I belong. This effectively signaled that he had bought into the conservative view that rights are not inherent to being human but granted by the powerful when and if they choose to do so.

Since the abortion issue is not the only right to life issue on our plate this year the evaluation of the leading candidates’ life values needs more analysis. At the moment it is clear to me that there is no truly pro life candidate being considered. Today (August 28) is the 45th anniversary of the "I have a dream" speech of Rev. Martin Luther King. He understood that the liberal ideal revealed in the founding documents was the dream that we all (or at least us liberals) seek. He quoted the pro life ideal, "We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal." Human rights acrue to humans because they are human not because the powerful choose to grant them.

Friday, April 25, 2008

How to be labeled as a liberal

In my formative years (I'm still being formed, however) it was clear to me that those Christians who took Jesus's words seriously and made a serious attempt to live them were inevitably identified as liberals. The workers of Catholic Charities or Lutheran Social Services, leaders and members of Catholic Worker Houses, Sisters of Mercy, Lay Missionaries in Central America, food shelf volunteers, soup kitchen volunteers and on and on. This is still true in large part today.

There were, of course, many non-christians, even athiests who considered themselves liberals but the strong emphasis of liberals on helping the poor and the hungry, the powerless and disenfrancised, those dehumanized because of their ethnicity , gender or race, and those being victimized by power, money or law creates a broad overlap with the directives of Jesus to treat all humans as though each was in fact Jesus himself.

You might say I became a liberal by the back door. That is my faith, when put into action, caused me to be identified as a liberal and the fit seemed to be fine. However, the last candidate for President I felt good about in the general election was Jimmy Carter. This was before abortion was an issue and his strong belief in the inalienable human rights of all human beings coincided with the Christian teaching about the dignity of all human beings. Since that time my presidential voting has been a painful process of choosing among less than acceptable alternatives.

If Carter were a candidate today I would have a problem because he has since moved to the right and bought into the conservative concept that some persons have rights only if granted them by the powerful or the majority.

The centrality of inalienable human rights in Christian thought, at least the Catholic Christian view, was demonstrated in Pope Benedict's talk to the United Nations last week. This point was made forcefully to the same body by John Paul II in earlier appearances at the UN.

Saturday, April 05, 2008

The Death of an American Hero

Forty years ago today Martin Luther King Junior, the American Christian leader, was assassinated in Memphis, Tn. It was a traumatic time. In many cities grief turned to anger and violence. In Indianapolis, however, there was little violence due, some think, to the fact that presidential candidate Bobby Kennedy attending a rally in the inner city told the crowd of Reverend King’s death and stood with them in solidarity. In the city where I lived a similar scene ensued.

Those of us who had been in the marches and protests seeking housing, employment and financial equality for our minority neighbors now went to our inner city to stand together in the solidarity of our shared grief. Opponent argued that doing this was offensive and that we should leave “them” to grieve alone in their own neighborhood. The example of the martyr reminded us God’s recommendation for our solidarity on this day.

“Blessed are they who mourn, for they will be comforted.” [Matthew 5:11, NAB]

In comparison to some other large cites our solidarity may have also earned us another blessing.

“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God.” [Matthew 5:9]

On the day of Reverend King’s funeral our city leaders planned a public commemoration at a downtown park scheduled for midday. I planned to take a vacation day so that I could participate fully in this event. I discovered, however, that while some of the African American employees wanted to attend but didn’t have the option of an impromptu vacation day as I did as a supervisor. I felt that additional employees might want to attend also. I approached the office manager a proposed that I and those employees that wished to attend the service would be granted an extended lunch break on that day. My status as a supervisor and the boss’s ok would shield the participating employees from any repercussions from peers or union rules. The plan was approved. This exercise in solidarity defused at least somewhat the fears rampant in the community and in our office. The prayers and the eulogies certainly helped us bear our grief.

A few years later I was introduced to an executive of the company. In an effort to place me he asked where I had worked. When I said that I had been a supervisor in city X in 1968 he said, “Oh, your that liberal supervisor that lead a walkout in city X.” This was an example of acting on Christian ideals getting me classified as politically liberal.

Wednesday, April 02, 2008

How I became a liberal

I do not remember deciding to be a liberal. It was more a matter of having been classified as a liberal by others. I was facinated by American democracy, however, and remember staying up late in August of 1956 listening (we did not have television) to the Democratic and Republican conventions. The Republicans went with the incumbent, Dwight Eisenhauer for president and the Democrats nominated Adlai Stevenson to opose him. Modern political conventions are boring in comparison.

Four years later I did choose to make some life altering decisions. Nancy and I were married and I discovered a relationship with God, a gift giving God. Thirty two years later, in writing a Theology of Ministry essay, I recalled this latter decision.

" . . . I awakened to the reality of a gift-giving God and the faith that opened the channel of personal relationship between us. Ministry, to date, has not been something I thought about but rather something I did in response to faith."1

I was not very good at responding to this new found faith as I began but my list of faith ideals did include the following:

  • "You shall love the Lord, your God, with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind." (Matthew 22:37, NAB)


  • "You shall love your neighbor as yourself." (Matthew 22:39,NAB)


  • "I say to you, whatever you did for one of these least (hungry, thirsty, naked, imprisoned) of mine, you did for me." (Matthew 25:40 NAB)2


As near as I can tell, it was taking these ideals seiously that got me classified as a liberal.

----------------

1 - "In Service to a gift giving God", Deacon Digest, November 1991
2 - See my posting "Christmas Message" on 2/26/08.

    Monday, February 18, 2008

    Real Life Human Rights Conflict

    Being a school holiday I am spending the morning at home with plenty to get done including taxes. In the background the TV is playing. As I pass through the room I hear the announcer saying that Bill Clinton is speaking at a Hilary rally in Wisconsin and that a number of Obama supporters are in the crowd raising uncomfortable questions for the "retired" president.

    As they go to a clip of the confrontation it is obvious that among them were human rights activists questioning why Hilary opposes the human rights of the fetus. The clip only showed his response which featured him shouting at the questioners, "we disagree with you! You want to penalize "mothers" and their doctors." How hard of hearing he must be. Here is a real life example of why Hilary is not liberal. It is also an example of why the human rights issue does not go away or get solved, what I have called the "human rights dilemma."

    When I was active in politics in an eastern state and an official in the local Democratic Party I had to opportunity to attend a number of events where Senator Bill Bradley was being honored or was a speaker. He always concluded by taking questions. At three events I was able to ask a question. Each time I asked him, a self identified liberal, how he could take a stand against the human rights of the fetus and support abortion for any reason?"

    In all three cases his answer was similar. (1)He did not deny that abortion was a human rights violation (he is reported to be quite intelligent). (2) He clearly said he put the "right" of the mother to terminate the life of her fetus for any reason above the right of her fetus to life.

    What Bill Clinton's anger graphically reveals is a "penalty" (Bill's word") or "Burden" view of competing human rights. He sees the human rights activists as seeking a "penalty" because he must see the human life of the fetus as a "penalty" or "burden". In fact the vast majority of human rights supporters do not see human rights as a competition in which some person's rights trump another's. The essential motivation of human rights activists is the protection of human rights.

    I do not know any human rights supporter who is opposed to "choice" by women or any other human being. Rather that somes ends or means that might be choosen are in fact violations of another human's right to life, liberty, property or citizenship among others. Yes, one can choose to violate someone else's right to choose. We have many examples in history and in our own day: slavery, election fraud, rape, blackmail among others. Honoring and protecting the rights of the fetus do not trump or deny the right to choose. Making rape a crime does not violate the rapist's right to choose rather his "choice" has violated her rights. The choice of abortion, likewise, does end the fetus' life while the mother and the doctor continue to have thier right to choose. ALL rights of the fetus have been terminated.

    I think there is a way to more constructively pursue human rights. Unfortunately the fork in the road to such an approach was passed long ago and over the last twenty years we have seen a steadily increasing disrespect for human rights in our country and in the world.

    Monday, February 11, 2008

    My Incomplete List of Liberal Ideals

    My Partial List of Liberal Ideals

    Reviewing my editorials on this topic to date I find I have listed the following as Political Liberal Ideals.


    Please note the word "Political". I am aware from comments on other blogs that some readers are not able to differntiate political, religious, mathmatical, and so forth use of language. Since I have given enough clues as to my religious world view and some readers may be aware of my training as a mathmatician there might be a temptation to apply the classifications I see as useful in one field and assume that I, the critic, would apply them undefined in the another field. Please avoid this temptation. In this series of blogs I am telling the story of the development my perspective on American Politics and making some amatuer diagnoses of the the current situation.

    Liberal Principles identified so far:

    I. All persons are created equal(1) and of equal dignity (2)

    II. In America, leaders serve at the consent of the governed. (3)

    III. Solidarity is the liberal modus operendi. (4)
    a. Solidarity moves citizens to action
    b. Polarity pertifies citizen action.


    ----------------------------------------
    Footnotes and Amplifications:

    (1) Sentence 1 of ,paragraph 2 of the American Declaration of Independance(1776),
    "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

    (2) As with any standard or ideal some means of measuring achievment of it in real life is necessary. The value "dignity" provides this measurability for the ideal of equality. Dignity (webster: meaning one)is the quality of being worthy, honored or asteemed. For example, persons are denied dignity because of race, sex, ethnicity, language, age or religion are in fact denied equality. This is only a partial list of criteria I have seen used to deny someone's dignity/equality in my life time.

    (3) Sentence 2 of Paragraph 2 of the American Declaration of Independance (1776),
    "That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,"

    (4) For many the first reaction to the word "Solidarity" is to think of the liberal movement in Poland that took this word as its name. Its roll in bringing down the reactionary goverment of their country in undeniable. Its meaning, however, is more universal and applical elsewhere.

    Webster: "Solidarity = Unity that produces (as in Poland) or is based on (as in US)
    community of interests, 0bjectives and standards.See 'Unity'."


    Saturday, February 09, 2008

    Human Rights Dilemma part two

    This morning I was able to view Mike Huckabee's talk to the Conservative Political Action Committee. His reception was only slightly more friendly than that given McCain yesterday. Like Obama he has the oritorical skills to communicate his vision and ideals. Unlike McCain, his statement of belief in the equality and dignity of all human life was not accompanied by an insistance that this an exclusive conservative value.

    I suspect his experience as a clergyman has made him aware that this ideal is in the hearts of most of us. In fact it is also at the center of the liberal democracy that makes America the beacon of freedom to millions around the world. And in politics it is in the soul of the liberal idea. A corolary liberal view is that in America the government serves at the conscent of the governed. The past twenty years this ideal has been eroded to the point when it is clear that neither political party any longer even takes note of this liberal ideal.

    The infusion of vast amounts of money into the process is indicative of the loss of these ideals by both parties. The very language most candidates for president use reveals this loss also. "Elect ME and I will solve your problems." I can hear this phrase clearly said again by many of our major candidates and his or her party label bears no correlation to his or her willingnes to say it over and over again.

    Those few candidates who are willing to say "let solve these problems by working together" are roundly attacked by both party establishments. The records and oratory of John McCain and Barack Obama are of this vein. I think the amazing awakening of the American Voter this year is the remergence of the citizens who feel in their gut that democracy cannot function without citizen participation. The message of solidarity moves us to action, the message of polarity pertifies us. This year many citizens are voting with their bodies and showing up to hear and to vote for those candidates who talk solidarity (an obviously liberal ideal) and not polarity.

    The behaviour of the major political parties has progressively alienated more and more of their members to the point where most Americans are neither Democrat nor Republican. In my own state a few years ago we even elected an independent as Governor. It turned out that he not only had no traditional political affiliation he had no political philosophy at all.

    I'm not sure this post moves me closer to my intended discussion of what I have labels the "Human Rights Dilemma". Perhaps next post I can get back to the story.


    Friday, February 08, 2008

    Human Rights Champions Dilemma

    I have put off writing about my countercultural understanding of political right and left. Having participted in and observed American political life for almost 50 years I have both a historical and an eclectic (some say sarcastic) view of politics.

    As a young adult I was entranced by American politics. I remember listening to the politcal conventions on radio, both parties. Those times are gone, we no longer have conventions but PR supershows. As I approached voting age Catholics finally were welcome on the politcal stage. In 1960 Nancy and I married, had our first child and I voted in my first presidential election.

    The challenge of JFK, "what can you do for your country", sounded like the true calling of citizenship envisioned by our founders. This year Barack Obama's idealism brings back that ancient thrill of citizenship. Many of my generation stepped up to JFKs challenge in the Peace Corp. In the process I and many others necessarily had to make some judgment as to where in the political spectrum My beliefs and values placed me.

    President Eisenhower's war hero status made him a great president but he was not accepted by his own party even if his warning about the Military Industrial Complex's impact on American ethical values proved to be true. As in any age, I suppose, my perspective is conditioned by what really happened on the ground, not what the books say or the idealogs claim.

    As the new democratic adminstration began to function a whole list of indicators came into synch with my Catholic values. The Cuban missle crisis was scary but a real life example of the use of military, power not to go to war, but to bring about a solution to a crisis short of war. I had been in the military and had been put on alert a number of time as the middle east moved into the turmoil we have known all these years.

    Civil rights, refugees welcomed from Cuba, all harminized with my Catholic belef that all persons were created equal and each was to be granted full dignity and respect. This became my view of being liberal, a view validated on the ground by real people literally living the value. Yesterday I heard John McCain say to the Conservative Political Action Committee that he held the fundamental conservative belief that "all persons were created equal." No wonder the conservatives hate him! That's the fundamental liberal belief!

    I will eventually get to the dilemma of the title of this posting but time and energy have run out for today.