Showing posts with label Health care reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Health care reform. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2012

SCOTUS and Healthcare reform

It should not be a surprise that a conservative court found a conservative healthcare reform law to be constitutional. It is still incredible that supposedly conservative politicians, including those that crafted the mandate approach, implemented and proved its effectiveness in a state are daily calling for its repeal.

This strikes me as sour grapes, that the first serious attempt to controls and reduce healthcare cost used their concepts but was championed by a Democratic President.

The SCOTUS ruling  apparently takes pains to clarify that it was ruling on the constitutionality of the law not it wisdom or popularity. We now have the added confusion of administrative rules, not specified by the legislature, that redefine what is and is not a religious institution. I suspect that another SCOTUS issue will have to deal with this affront to the first Amendment.

Tuesday, February 07, 2012

Senator Santorum Wins Big - Then another Stumper

By the time most of you read this you will know that Senator Santorum, my favorite Republican presidential candidate, won two and maybe three of today's caucus states. I just listened to his victory speech and he again restated his belief that the government created our right  to health care and even claims that President Obama agrees with him! If he is right then President Obama is in fact well to the right of the Senator on this issue (which I suspect is the case).

See my research and reading on Senator's position on human rights in the previous posting. I have probably bored you with the story of the courting I received from Republicans following my departure from the Democratic party in the early 1990s. The first issue relates to abortion and the fact that most republicans that approached me were pro abortion. The second most impressive position came from Republicans that claimed to be 'conservative' and their marketing talking point was that government created rights. Sometimes it was couched in terms a strange 'American Exceptionalism' that says that only Americans have human rights because only the America's government has created them.

I think I was always classified as a liberal because I believed that human rights accrue to all human person because they are human and I adhere to a matching religious world view that human are 'endowed by their creator' with such rights. Thus as in the first issue I found it incompatible with my liberal ideals to join with a party that argues against the idea of inherent  or as our founders said, unalienable Rights that preceded any action by government.

Now Senator Santorum did allude to the Declaration and did state that he believes that human rights are from God, a view I share, but then makes a case by attacking the health care reform that we humans in fact have no right to health care. POW! Take that you poor people, here, one more for all the former middle class who who have been denied or lost their health insurance. I suspect that he is only the most articulate of the field which probably holds the same view.

The strangest aspect of the argument he made is that President Obama agrees  with him about creating a right which has the effect of placing the President in a more 'conservative' position than Rick himself since he believes that rights are God given, a clearly more liberal view in my experience. In addition I  suspect his 'conservatism' bars believing in the the phase,  "That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed."  from the founding document.

If you are getting the idea that I'm really not impressed by the fuzz generated by our politicians this week (read  my last several political postings critical of both Republican and Democratic candidates) you got it right.

Senator Santorum vs Human Rights

If you have been following my commentary on the Republican Primary you are probably right in concluding that Rick Santorum is my favorite. Then the other day I came upon a TV clip of Rick Santorum being interviewed by someone. I couldn’t believe what I heard him say. Before I could determine the full context of the video it was gone. What I found so unsettling was that he appeared to say  that human rights are created by government and that no one has a right to health care.

I spent significant time over the last few days trying to confirm the context of the video or determine what Mr. Santorum’s position was regarding the source of human rights. I read through all likely position papers on his web site and could not determine the answer. I have heard him and other ‘conservatives’ quote from the declaration of Independence the clause that is the core credo of the liberal view of democracy (see footnote).”He even titles one of his issue sections “We hold these truths…”  where he does support some of positions that I do he seems convinced that human rights can be terminated or created by government,. This is not quite what the founders had in mind! 
I Did not find the video but I did come across a written discussion between Rick and Hugh Hewitt (talk show host and Law professor) that did lay it out pretty clearly. Sadly my first impression was right! Here is Rick Santorum scolding the Catholic Bishops and in the process confirming his rejection of the founding idea that “’…to secure these rights government is instituted..”:

“I hate to say it, but you know, you (the bishops) had it coming. And it’s time to wake up and realize that government isn’t the answer to the social ills. It’s people of faith, and it’s families, and it’s communities, and it’s charities that need to do this as it has in America so successfully for so long.”   (Click here for the whole interview.)  

Whew! The need of humans for health care is a social ill? I think the bishops are closer to the truth, everyone should be able to get health care. I think it’s a violation of human dignity to deny anyone health care. That is the language of human rights, unalienable rights if you like .An economic and governmental environment that denies health care to any one is a violation of human rights. The resulting suffering is a social ill. Our government was instituted to ‘secure’ such rights and yes then persons, families, churches, charities, communities and businesses can better provide health care to all. 

Footnotes-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Liberal Credo: We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,  that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, ... (http://www.ushistory.org/declaration/document/)

Saturday, February 04, 2012

Conscience Protection for Religious Institutions

Today I sent the following email to my US Congressman:

I request that you urgently communicate to the President the displeasure of many Minnesotans with the unreasonable narrow criteria for conscience protections by the HHS regulations concerning the provision of insurance for employees under the health care reform law. That criterion is so narrow that many churches, most religiously run schools and all religiously run hospitals in our mostly rural area will be forced to fund insurance coverage of actions abhorrent to their ethical standards.
I urge you to support in congress a measure that would restore conscience protection for religious institutions that many voters feel the president had promised during the health care reform discussions. The first article of the Bill of Rights (Religious liberty) has been held in high regard by Democratic, Republican and independent citizens for over 200 years. Do not let this become a partisan issue now.

I urge my fellow citizens to contact his or her Congressman on this matter as soon as possible. Here in Minnesota political caucuses  will be held this week. Please attend your party's caucus and bring this issue to your fellow citizens attention. If you are religious I urge you to pray, starting now, that wisdom visit our civil leaders on this matter.

Saturday, November 19, 2011

Where Did Healthcare Reform Come From?

The endless round of debates between Republican Candidates for President have established quite clearly that the Health Care Reform the previous congress enacted came from conservative proposals offered in response to the 1990s effort by Hilary Clinton to address the problem and from subsequent demonstrations in the states, particularly Massachusetts,  of its feasibility, workability and legality.  This leaves one puzzled as to the real reasons behind the  loudly proclaimed opposition to the reform as 'liberal' or 'socialist'.  Outside of Congress the support for reforming health care came from a wide spectrum of citizens, health care organizations, churches and organizations that are not particularly liberal in their point of view.

The characterization of the reform as "Obomacare" strikes most voters as indicative of blatant opposition to the President as a person rather than any realistic attack on the reforms themselves. In a similar vein, the charge that 'Obama cut Medicare by $500m' is used to label the fact that the reform reduced Medicare costs, a goal supported by both Democratic and Republican candidates over several election cycles.

The reality is that the reform is not perfect and groups on the left, on the right and among human right supporters have good reasons to ask for changes to the law whereas its repeal would not solve those problems but would set back the human right to health care by several decades and return us to the rapid increase in health care cost that is inevitable without reform.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Conscience Protection for Healthcare Professionals

The new health care reforms that are now part of federal law are quite weak if not a step backwards on conscience protection for health care professionals. In our federal system, however, each state can act to fill in the gaps left in federal law. We now have three states (Louisiana, Mississippi and Idaho) that provide comprehensive conscience protection. Idaho is the latest addition to this list. Here is a portion of a report on that development from Americans united for life (AUL):

“Idaho has become the third state to provide comprehensive protection for health care freedom of conscience. Governor Butch Otter has permitted Senate Bill 1353 to go into effect without his signature. AUL worked with Idaho Chooses Life, a state pro-life policy group, to help enact this important legislation.

The new law protects any licensed health care professional from being required to participate in “any health care service that violates his or her conscience.” “Health care service” is specifically defined to include “abortion, dispensation of an abortifacient drug, human embryonic stem cell research, treatment regimens utilizing human embryonic stem cells, human embryo cloning or end of life treatment or care.” A health care professional declining to participate in these services may not be discriminated against or held liable for exercising his or her conscience.”


Read the entire article here.

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

The Church’s Teaching and Health Reform

The Church’s social doctrine directly addresses the situation faced by Congressman Stupak. He clearly has been working to assure that loopholes that could be exploited by the marketplace to fund human rights violations (abortions) with tax dollars are not permitted to be used for that purpose.

A honest review of Mr Stupak’s efforts, the church’s teaching (CSDC: Paragraph 570) and the events of the last week reveal that he has conformed to the teaching in every detail. In fact the bill is not an abortion bill but a repair of our busted health care system consistent with the principle of subsidiarity and whose effect is to restore to the family its rightful role as a subsidiary social unit in providing health care for its members. The marketplace has rationed, restricted and denied the resources needed by millions of American families and individuals to receive health care. A hundred years of federal leaders and the efforts of 50 state governments have not been able to bring this restoration of equity and justice to individual’s access to health care. Paragraph 570 of the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church says:

“570. When — concerning areas or realities that involve fundamental ethical duties — legislative or political choices contrary to Christian principles and values are proposed or made, the Magisterium teaches that “a well-formed Christian conscience does not permit one to vote for a political programme or an individual law which contradicts the fundamental contents of faith and morals”[1191]. In cases where it is not possible to avoid the implementation of such political programmes or to block or abrogate such laws, the Magisterium teaches that a parliamentary representative, whose personal absolute opposition to these programmes or laws is clear and known to all, may legitimately support proposals aimed at limiting the damage caused by such programmes or laws and at diminishing their negative effects on the level of culture and public morality. In this regard, a typical example of such a case would be a law permitting abortion[1192]. The representative's vote, in any case, cannot be interpreted as support of an unjust law but only as a contribution to reducing the negative consequences of a legislative provision, the responsibility for which lies entirely with those who have brought it into being.

Faced with the many situations involving fundamental and indispensable moral duties, it must be remembered that Christian witness is to be considered a fundamental obligation that can even lead to the sacrificing of one's life, to martyrdom in the name of love and human dignity[1193]. The history of the past twenty centuries, as well as that of the last century, is filled with martyrs for Christian truth, witnesses to the faith, hope and love founded on the Gospel. Martyrdom is the witness of one who has been personally conformed to Jesus crucified, expressed in the supreme form of shedding one's blood according to the teaching of the Gospel: if “a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies ... it bears much fruit” (Jn 12:24).” [CSDC © USSB, 2004]

It is clear that it is the federal government’s turn to attempt to force the marketplace to facilitate the return of this function to the family and the individual. This is necessary because the marketplace has demonstrated repeatedly its cruel unwillingness to bring about justice on this matter and insists on giving more homage to profits than to human rights.

Is it a “take over” of health care? In the sense of making it possible for the family to have the power rather than the marketplace it facilitates such a take over by the appropriate and lowest social level competent to exercise that power, the family and the individual.


Is it a “Government takeover”? Since it mostly addresses the cost of and the mechanism of paying for health care the current bill primarily provides regulation of the insurance portion of the market. A high level of Government (States) already regulates health care insurance it hard to see this as more government takeover. It does seem to address the obvious inequities and injustices between states often unfairly visited on those families who must or do move often from state to state. Lastly, since millions of older Americans are covered by Medicare or VA insurance (Government Insurance) there is nothing introduced by the current bill that rivals their size.

Will the anti human rights elements of the marketplace try to use this change to enrich themselves? I am sure they will as they most certainly would have if the Republicans had championed the correction when they were the majority in Congress. They do not intend to give up and neither should we.

However, they, the abortion industry in particular, will lose a big lever they now have to argue that their services, the termination of the life in the womb, cost much less than having and raising the child. The restoration of access to health care to families and individuals especially those at the lower economic levels will remove much of this lever from the abortionist tool bag.

Saturday, February 27, 2010

The Facts Please

Unlike the hysteria of last year about "OBAMACARE" (there were actually a score or so plans being proposed by legislators that came down two Bills at the end of the year) we now actually have a plan that the President has taken ownership of and discussed with legislators this week. It purports to be a combining of the Senate and House bills with additional features to make it more fiscally conservative.

I heard only a portion of the discussion but I did hear both the President and Representative Pelosi claim that the new proposal would prohibit the spending of tax dollars for abortions. Since they also said their plan did not include the Stupak Amendment (found in the House Bill) in this matter but rather the language from the Senate Bill their claim was incorrect. Americans United for Life, one of the calmer and more rigorous researcher of facts on this human rights issue, has an analysis of the facts found , not in the political pronouncements, but in the text of the bills at issue.



Speaker Pelosi and the Senate Bill refer to the Hyde Amendment which prohibits tax dollars being spent on abortion in Medicare as the "status qua" and claim that its provisions will remain. The Stupak Amendment prohibits the spending of tax dollars for the provision of abortions under the federal mandates and funding of this reform.

Since we heard several proposals to end Medicare at the recent conservative (TP & CPAC) conferences and the abortion lobby has plenty of resources to twist political arms the reliance on a weak link between Medicare (Public Health Care Insurance) and the reformed rules for private health care and health insurance it is not sufficient to assure the prohibition to the use of our federal tax dollars for abortion in the long run.

At least 70% of Americans oppose the use of their tax dollars for abortions. I think politicians of all parties need to take the views of this majority seriously. Despite the PR of the abortion lobby and the claims of some popular commentators, the Stupak Amendment DOES NOT outlaw abortion or "choice". It does, however, protect citizens from being forced to pay for abortions.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Finally Healthcare Reform?

It looks like we will see health care reform of some kind from Washington in a few weeks. Sadly we might have arrived at this point earlier if the supposed supporters of human rights had stuck to their values and not bargained them away for pork!

The classic case, of course, is Ben Nelson on Nebraska who accepted taxpayer funding of abortion in return for a special Medicare discount for the citizens of his state. As a result he is unlikely to be reelected and his constituents won't see their pork either. Had he and others continued to support the human rights position the Senate bill likely would have had the Stupak amendment included (prohibiting the use of taxes for abortion) and the Senate and House bills would have likely been reconciled with much less angst and markedly more public support (70% of American oppose the use of Taxes to fund abortion) including the Catholic Bishops.

The Stupak amendment is about prohibiting the use of taxes to pay for abortions. Despite the decades long prohibition on the use of taxes for abortion, known as the Hyde amendment, the pro abortion commentators are loudly claiming that Stupak would outlaw abortion or oppose choice. Since the amendment clearly does neither this deliberate distortion should be obvious. In fact, what they (the abortion industry) want is tax dollars that we, the citizens, would have to pay without any choice.

Again I urge you to support health care reform but to insist that it be done so that our taxes are not used for abortions and medical professionals' conscience rights are protected.

Pawlenty: Trying to end healthcare justice in Minnesota

In less than six weeks GAMC, Minnesota's General Assistance Medical Care program for the poorest and sickest Minnesotans will end at the hand of Governor Pawlenty. He has vetoed the extension of the program passed overwhelmingly by the State Senate (46 to 16) and the State House of representatives (125 to 9) a few weeks ago. If this cruel veto is not overridden we will take two giant steps backwards in health care justice in our State.

Please call or Email your State Representative and Senator and insist they vote to override the veto.

To find your Senator's Email address click on this link:
http://www.senate.leg.state.mn.us/members/member_list.php?ls=85&sort=a

To find your representative's Email address click on this link:
http://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/members/housemembers.asp

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Bishops Reaffirm Health Care Reform Support

The US Catholic Bishops are meeting in Baltimore and along with approving a new document on Marriage have reaffirmed their support of health care reform. Here is s short quote from the Baltimore Sun's article on the meeting.

"The bishops meet little more than a week after their successful lobbying effort to strengthen restrictions on abortion in the House version of health care overhaul. That effort led Rep. Lynn Woolsey, a California Democrat, to suggest that the IRS review the church's tax exemption.

The bishops have long called for universal access to health care, but oppose abortion. O'Brien and others have said it is appropriate for Catholics to join the health care debate.

In a statement Tuesday, Cardinal Francis George of Chicago, the president of the conference, said they "remain deeply concerned about the debate that now moves to the Senate, especially as it will affect the poor and vulnerable, and those at the beginning and end of life."

I wonder if Congressman Woolsey will be calling for a review of my tax status (or that of 40 of his fellow democratic congressmen) since I (they) also support health care reform and oppose classifying the human right violation of abortion as health care or the use of tax dollars to pay for it.

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

A Special Plea To Senators Grassley & Issacson

I was pleased to hear President Obama single out Senator Grassley of Iowa as an example of a conservative who is serious about health care reform. I was pleased because the Senator and I are both Pro-Life even though we are of opposite political party it is important that pro-life voices remain involved in this effort as the Human rights stakes are too-too high.

As of now, however, I am convinced he has given up the pro-life effort in this matter. On several channels this evening Senator Grassley was seen and heard lying to my generation (I am 70) about a element of one of the health care bills being considered (there are many). The wording of the provision, I understand was a verbatim match with a provision of an earlier bill sponsored by several Republican Senators, including Senator Issacson of Georgia, that provide that consultations about end of life care with your doctor, Hospice (usually a Charity), your lawyer might be paid by your insurance.

Now, Senator Issacson, is also Pro-life and was also named by the President as a Conservative who was serious about health care. While the Senator from Iowa is of special interest as a neighbor and I was careful to hear him in his own words.I understand, again from reports on more than one channel, that Senator Issacson has also removed himself from the healthcare discussion.

Having sat in on these kinds of consultations with several relatives they do not relate at all to the lies we are now hearing. This is bad news indeed. We need these pro-life voices in the discussion! We will get healthcare reform with human rights and conscience protections or without them. I urge both of them to return to the table and certainly stop lying to us Seniors and playing on our fears. The stakes are too high. Tell the anti life forces to get off your backs and let you do your jobs.

Senators, please turn your backs on the anti life forces that have convinced you (perhaps through economic pressure?) to compromise your human rights ideals and and honesty with us seniors.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Abortion Funding Under Cover of Healthcare

There is much discussion in our media of health care reform. It is every where. It on TV,newspapers, the Internet and in our day to day conversations. Just this past weekend at a family gathering health care discussions were heard from time to time, some heated.

This evening I listened in on part of a huge Internet Pro Life meeting that featured speakers from a great diversity of organizations. Religious, non religious, men, women, liberals, conservatives were all heard expressing their concern that the human rights of the unborn will be further violated if abortion is mandated in the health care reform being considered in congress.

Recently in a meeting with Catholic Media Mr Obama said that he had more or less put the Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) on the back burner. However, if abortion were to become a mandated benefit under national health care reform a major portion of FOCA would be accomplished.

Despite the opposition of a majority of Americans to abortion and even larger opposition to forced funding of abortions by those who oppose such human rights violations (see my earlier postings about polls concerning abortion) many in Congress appear willing to do just that. We would be forced to do this through taxes for government plans (existing and proposed) and through premiums for open market insurance plans.

We need to urge our Representatives and Senators to keep abortion out of health care.

An action plan to help keep FOCA out of health care can be found here. Its first suggestion can and should be implemented by all, PRAY. Then get to your representative and Senators about your concern using your preferred means (mail, phone, Email).